The latest sale at 110 €/100 kg clearly contradicts the European Milk Board's call to reduce intervention stocks in a way that will not be detrimental to the market and without selling skimmed milk powder below market value. The largest volume of skimmed milk powder to date – 4,337 tons – was rejected in the most recent tendering process. Since December 2016, 6,421 tons of SMP have been sold as part of 17 calls for tender. About 380,000 tons are still sitting in European intervention storage. The current market price for skimmed milk powder has fallen to 137 €/100 kg.
"Unfortunately, the powder was not sold but outright dumped – this price is scandalous," says the president of the European Milk Board, Romuald Schaber, outraged by the European Commission's behaviour. "You have the feeling that the Commissioner for Agriculture is trying to get rid of stocks without any concern for the consequences." Dumping milk powder in this fashion is very dangerous considering the current market situation and makes conditions even more difficult for milk producers, adds the president of the EMB. "Even the minimum price of 215.10 €/100 kg set in December 2016 does not actually correspond to real production value," continues Schaber. "By steadily reducing the selling price to a mere 110 €, policy-makers continue sending the wrong signs."
After a short-lived recovery, milk prices are already showing a downward trend. German and Belgian dairy farmers have reported a price reduction of about 4 - 10 cents in past weeks. With the projected production increases in coming months, Europe's dairy farmers are heading into the next crisis with their eyes wide open.
Sieta van Keimpema, milk producer from the Netherlands and vice-president of the EMB, remains pragmatic. "Agriculture Commissioner Hogan assured us milk producers that the voluntary production cuts instrument continues to be available at EU level. Mr Commissioner, NOW would be the time to follow through on your assurances and to introduce a new volume reduction programme that includes production caps, as proposed in our Market Responsibility Programme!"
For the EMB it is crystal clear that intervention is ineffective in the face of chronic market instabilities and suppresses future selling prices, thus counteracting market recovery. Instead, production must be aligned with market needs through volume reduction.
Market Responsibility Programme – MRP
The MRP is a programme for the EU milk sector that is to be used when there is a risk of a milk market imbalance. A combination of monitoring and response to the market enables impending crises to be recognised and reacted to in a three-phase programme.
Recognising crises – Market Index
- A Market Index comprising the trend in product quotations, milk prices and production costs (margin) enables crises to be anticipated.
- If the index is over 100, the prices are covering the production costs – the market is stable, no action needs to be taken. If the index falls below the 100 threshold, costs are not being covered. If the shortfall is too big, the Market Responsibility Programme is started.
Reacting to crises – applying the MRP
The implementation of the MRP is set to take place in three phases.
1. Early warning (Market Index falls by 7.5 %)
2. Crisis (Market Index falls by 15 %)
- Monitoring agency announces early warning
- Private storage is opened
- Incentive programmes for extra consumption such as sucking-calf production, milk fattening of heifers etc.
- Phase is maintained until the index returns to 100
3. Obligatory cutback phase (Market Index falls by 25 %)
- The crisis is officially established and announced by the Monitoring Agency
- Core elements of the Market Responsibility Programme are started
- A reference period is defined
- Call for tenders regarding voluntary production cuts (at least 5 %), bonus for reducing production
- Market responsibility levy from the first kilo for farms increasing production
- Universally applicable reduction in the supply of milk by 2–3 % for a defined
- Universally applicable reduction in the supply of milk by 2–3 % for a defined period, e.g. 6 months
End of the crisis – crisis measures lifted
If the index trend continues towards 100 points and the Monitoring Agency’s forecasts for the further market development are positive, the crisis can be declared over. On this date all measures restricting production end. Commitments entered into on a voluntary, contractual basis end as agreed.
Please click here for further details about the MRP